Parshat Vayetzei with Rabbi Alissa Wise

About the episode

Parshat Vayetzei 5787
Beresheet 28:10–32:3
Guest: Rabbi Alissa Wise

@alissashira
@Rabbis4Ceasefire 
@Jewishdiasporamovement

Rabbis for Ceasefire
Solidarity is the Political Version of Love: Lessons from Jewish Anti-Zionist Organizing

* * *

Support Left at Sinai! https://www.gofundme.com/f/support-left-at-sinai-progressive-parshat-hashavuah-podcast

Transcript: arianakatz.com/leftatsinai

Sponsor an episode by giving at the link above, then filling out this form: bit.ly/leftatsinaisponsor

Host: Rabbi Ariana Katz | arianakatz.com | @rabbiariana

hinenubaltimore.org | @hinenubaltimore

fortimessuchasthesebook.com | @fortimessuchasthesebook

Editing: Ev Bowen | @evanbowen.jpeg

Music: Gevurah by Molly Bajgot | mollybajgot.com | @mollybajgot

Art: Liora Ostroff | lioraostroff.com | @lioraostroff

Transcript

Shavua tov. We have made it to a new week, and we are here in Parshat Vayeitzei. I am so excited to bring you the vibrant, flirty, life-affirming Torah of Rabbi Elissa Wise for this week's parsha. This week's learning is sponsored by Fringes: Feminist Non-Zionist Havurah, ongoing for nearly 20 years, in appreciation for the leadership, scholarship, and liturgy of Elliot Bat Sadek.

This week's parsha is Parshat Vayetze, Bereshit 28:10 through 32:3, and I am thrilled to be joined today by my friend and teacher, Rabbi Elissa Wise. Elissa Wise is the founding director of Rabbis for Ceasefire and co-founder of the Jewish Diaspora Movement. She is co-author of Solidarity is the Political Version of Love: Lessons from Jewish Anti-Zionist Organizing. Thanks for teaching us Torah, Rabbi Elissa Wise.

Rabbi Alissa Wise: Well, I haven't taught you Torah yet, so

AK: I

gratitude. It's, you know, moda ani

Alissa Wise 1:12

Oh, no, yeah.

Ariana 1:14

can you give us a quick rundown of what happens in this week's parsha?

Alissa Wise 1:18

Well, there actually are a lot of, like, greatest hits in this parsha. I mean, that's kind of what Bereshit is kind of known for, right? It's like, e- everything we know is in Bereshit. I think it like, then we get on and people are like, "That ever happened?" Okay, so it opens with Jacob's ladder, ye old Jacob's ladder, where he, where he dreams a ladder going, with angels going up and down. Then moves into the song, which you went to Jewish day school, right, Arianna? So did you sing the song Ufaratzta?

Ariana 1:56

Oh, yeah

Alissa Wise 1:57

Ufaratzta, ufaratzta, ufaratzta, ufaratzta, Yamav. So that is in this parsha.

Ariana 2:05

to?

Alissa Wise 2:06

it's like, "You shall be spread out to the north and the south and the west and the east." And it's interesting, 'cause like when I read it, like immediately I started humming the song in my head, and then I was like, "Wait a minute, why did we sing that at a Zionist Jewish day school?" Like, what?

Ariana 2:22

I can't imagine why sing a song about spreading out? So that is, so after he ascends and, or imagines these angels ascending and descending the ladder, speaks to him in this

Alissa Wise 2:38

Yes. Yes. Oh, yes. Yes.

Ariana 2:40

the covenant."

Alissa Wise 2:41

Yes, exactly. And so th- then comes the next greatest hit, which is infamous or famous, depending how you think about it, from the Jewish wedding ceremony of the bedecken, the checking, right? Because Jacob finds himself... He encounters Rachel, and he, like, is smitten with her and wants her to be his. And he goes to her father and he's like, "Well, you have to work for me for seven years in order to get her." And he's like, "That's totally worth it." And then w- after the seven years, the father does a bait and switch and gives him this older sister, Leah, instead. And so this is from, this is the story from which the tradition goes that we do a bedeken before signing the ketubah at a wedding ceremony, because what if somebody's father has bait and switched and put an older sister in place of whoever it was that you thought that you wanted to marry? so I feel like that's kind of like an interesting parsha because it goes from, you know, this like really kind of psychedelic l- ladder dream to like really intense covenant vow in relationship with God to this like romance intrigue and conniving father, and then kind of comes back around towards the end of the portion back to the connection with God and the commandments and his commitment to serve God and/or God's commitment to be a partner to him wherever he will go, right? So there's... I was, when I was rereading it, I thought there's this part that kind of actually reminds me of the Ruth and Naomi story, because God is kind of like, "Wherever you go, I will go." Like, almost and and, um, and which we get later in that story that we typically read during Shavuot. But so on one foot, that's kind of what happens in the parsha

Ariana 5:04

Yeah, I mean, there is this, um, there's a new theology that's developed in this moment, and I learned this from Dr. Elsie Stern when she talks about the the idea that God can be anywhere and is not specific is actually an innovation in in Israelite theology. And one midrash that understands the angels going up and down the ladder is the shift is changing because he's leaving one arrondissement and moving into the next, angels that'll- can cover him in the next place. But that God is like, "No, I'm not the God of just in Canaan. I'm the God wherever you go."

Alissa Wise 5:42

Yeah

Ariana 5:42

itself is this innovation

Alissa Wise 5:44

Right. And there was ano- there's another Midrash about the ladder, which is that where it goes to is the temple in Yerushalayim. And so it's like, which is kind of amazing, like it's like a portal, and like that is really interesting to me. You know, obviously, as you mentioned when you introduced me, I'm part, a co-founder of the Jewish Diaspora movement, so obviously really interested in, when our Torah kind of touches on what is our relationship to diaspora and exile. where does the ladder go, right? And so it, I love the idea that like it all goes to the temple. Like from the place of like wherever you are, you actually have access to the temple, right? That this ladder could take you wherever into that, to that central place where God lives. So That little Midrash in particular for that reason. But I have other things I want to talk to you about this portion. I don't... When you're ready. When you're ready

Ariana 6:42

wanna get there, I just, it feels really important for our listeners who know your work and your organizing to hear you talking about diaspora leads to the temple in Jerusalem, for us to tease apart a piece of anti-Zionist theology here that,

Alissa Wise 6:59

Yeah.

Ariana 6:59

I mean, I learned from you that we've been developing together with so

Alissa Wise 7:03

Yeah

Ariana 7:04

comrades through the generations, which is it is possible to yearn for a Jerusalem of peace. It is yearn for a Jerusalem of peace, that talking about the temple is not the Third Temple movement, is not

Alissa Wise 7:22

Yes

Ariana 7:22

who are doing the ufarzta in a way that we understand God not to have meant. And but if you are new to hearing anti-Zionist Jews who love Torah talk about Torah, you might be surprised when you hear Rabbi Alyssa Wise say "Oh my God, I'm so excited. This temple, wherever the base of it is in diaspora, leads us to the temple in Jerusalem." That i- that a surprise, I think, for some people

Alissa Wise 7:46

Well, so for me, part of the way that I relate to it is that the idea that there is this central place in Jerusalem is like this, like, original myth of Israelite religion, right? And Judaism takes it out of that idea, right? Like, Judaism is a tradition that then takes that as metaphor, right? And that we can live and make home and build solidarity and mu- relationships of mutual interdependence wherever we live and still have that tether to the divine, wherever that is. And so there's lots of different spiritual technologies that the rabbis developed for that, right? The latter is one. The, you know, this is also in Torah, but I think the rabbis take it to a new place of, like, the traveling Mishkan and prayer three times a- There's all these different technologies that have been developed to, like, continue to tether us to that core spiritual metaphor of being away from the source, right? And that's how I see it, is that that's, like, the kind of driving spiritual metaphor in Judaism that is the work of a Jewish life is to yur- work for redemption, right? And so we have these myths of redemption in our, and metaphors of redemption in our tradition. And so it reminds us that, like, that's what it means to be a Jew, is you're, like, always working for that. And that can be, for us, a lot of us think about that as freedom and equality and justice for people, which another person might have that same commitment and call it, like, reunification with the divine, right? And so that's kind of the core of the diasporas Torah and the diasporas spiritual life that I like to live.

Ariana 9:36

The, the ladder is sometimes a StairMaster. You have to work really hard to try to get somewhere. It's not moving you. Okay. Thank

Alissa Wise 9:43

that

Ariana 9:45

Where do you wanna go with this week's parsha?

Alissa Wise 9:48

so here's the thing, is that of course, like, it's funny that you brought me there to talk about diasporism, but I was like, I actually don't wanna talk... There is a lot that we could, we could have a whole diasporist podcast about this parsha, let's just say that. wouldn't it be fun if we just talked about something that, like, I actually never talk about in public? Like, like, is not part... Yeah. Like, let me, let's just try on

Ariana 10:10

We need your other Torah. We, we have

Alissa Wise 10:12

Okay

Ariana 10:12

of your diasporism Torah. Give us something else

Alissa Wise 10:15

Okay, so there's a lot of sex and romance in this parsha, and I want to ex- and I noticed it, but the rabbis also noticed it, so I thought it would be fun for us to kind of go in. I did some research to prepare some Midrashim, largely from Bereishit Rabba, which is the, the Midrash of the rabbis extrapolating and telling stories and fan-ficcing, as my 13-year-old likes to call it, of of what happens in the parsha. And it's also just to say that the rabbis also are very worried that there should be something wrong with the Torah, right? So they're always reading to make it make sense to th- their worldview, right? That there can't be an errant word or an insinuation that one of the Avot, one of the patriarchs, did something Tor- untorah, right? So you have to, like, redeem it, right? And that's kind of the work of the rabbis. Okay, so let's take an example. So we're not gonna go in order of the parsha, just because I feel like, why? Okay, so if we look at Genesis 29:11 this is the part where we said that he, where we talked about the where Jacob meets Rachel, and he is, you know, really smitten with her. And of course, he meets at a, a w- spring or at a well. There's a lot of meeting at the well, water, like places where water comes together is obvi- always a thing in Torah that where something, some romance or some relationship is, is fostered. So 28-- 29:11, it says, "Then Jacob kissed Rachel and broke into tears." So, you know, we are starting off small with kissing, right? So, okay, so he kissed...

Ariana 12:19

cry, it's so good

Alissa Wise 12:21

Have you ever had a kiss that made you cry?

Ariana 12:24

Yeah.

Alissa Wise 12:26

Yeah,

Ariana 12:26

it

Alissa Wise 12:26

it's like a really, it changes your life. Like, you're like, and I, you know. So it's like a very relatable thing, and it's kind of like, it's like one of those things like when you know, you know, you know? Like,

Ariana 12:37

Yeah

Alissa Wise 12:38

so it's actually, like from a romance, like I'm a very rom-com reader and watcher of movies. So like, we know this of like the meet cute, right? So this is basically like Jacob's and Rachel's m- meet cute, and it's like not just like, "Oh, you're cute," but like actually like, "Kissing you changed my life." Okay, so the rabbis are like, "Wait a minute. How is Jacob kissing Rachel before they are wedded," right? Like, they don't say that, but that i- is implied. So in Bereishit Rabba they say Jacob kissed Rachel, right? So they're gonna like say, what is, what's, what about this kiss. Every kiss is for promiscuity except for three. Okay, so there's, every ti-

Ariana 13:24

is slutty except if it's in these three categories.

Alissa Wise 13:28

Right.

Ariana 13:29

great. r- listener, you need to know that the rabbis are really horny, and that they're doing a lot, they're doing a lot of talking about sex, and they get to say no, we're just talking about it for the sake of Torah," but it's just a bunch of dudes in a room talking about sex.

Alissa Wise 13:47

Right

Ariana 13:48

there's like a... It's a very charged environ. So now they're gonna get into the details of what are the kinds of

Alissa Wise 13:52

Right.

Ariana 13:52

aren't,

Alissa Wise 13:53

What are the, what are three kinds of kissing that aren't slutty? I mean, do you have any guesses? Like, what, what, what would a sl- non-slutty kiss be?

Ariana 14:00

Oh, this is a great question. Non-slutty kisses. Kissing the Torah is not

Alissa Wise 14:05

Oh, nice

Ariana 14:07

Torah podcast, just for the record.

Alissa Wise 14:08

Yeah.

Ariana 14:09

Um, kissing the Torah, Kissing the Torah is not slutty. Kissing someone in greeting like a,

Alissa Wise 14:14

Oh, nice. Yeah, That's good

Ariana 14:18

Like kissing sacred, like ritual objects in general, I would include kissing land under that category. Kissing family the like, the greeting farewell

Alissa Wise 14:31

Right

Ariana 14:32

I don't know. Are there any other

Alissa Wise 14:34

All right.

Ariana 14:36

What all you got?

Alissa Wise 14:36

So here's what the rabbis say. The three kisses that are not slutty are a kiss of greatness, a kiss of reunion, and a kiss of parting. So a kiss of greatness, there, so there's gonna be a proof text for everything, right? So this comes from 1 Samuel, where Samuel says, where it says, "Samuel took the flask of oil, poured onto his head, and kissed him." So it's like an honorific kiss, you know? Like you're giving honor

Ariana 15:13

Saul

Alissa Wise 15:14

Yeah.

Ariana 15:15

Okay

Alissa Wise 15:17

So that's, you know, it's like a m- it's kinda, I think of that as the bubbe kiss that you described. I know it's not because he's anointing Saul, but you know.

Ariana 15:29

Yeah

Alissa Wise 15:30

All right

Ariana 15:30

It's the mannerly kiss.

Alissa Wise 15:33

Yeah.

Ariana 15:34

Okay

Alissa Wise 15:35

All right, a kiss of reunion. So you haven't seen somebody in a long time, and you give them a kiss to say, "I'm so glad to see you again." So this is Exodus 4:27. "He went and he met him at the mountain of God and he kissed him." Okay. So he had, and a kiss of parting. "Orpah kissed her mother-in-law, but Ruth clung to her." From the Book of Ruth. Again, a mention of Book of Ruth. So basically, if this was a kiss of greatness, then Jac- then Jacob would not have been a slut. If it was a kiss of reunion, it would not have been a slut, and if it was a kiss of parting. Now, was it any of these things?

Ariana 16:23

And the rabbis are gonna need

Alissa Wise 16:24

In your estimation?

Ariana 16:26

Well, knowing

Alissa Wise 16:27

They will want it. Well, what do you think? Like, could we read it as a kiss of greatness?

Ariana 16:34

love that idea. I think about, the, the ways in which when we talk about, sexual freedom and one-night stands, like Andrew Ramer's blessing for a one-night stand that again invokes

Alissa Wise 16:50

Yes

Ariana 16:51

right? There is a way of having a first kiss or a casual sexual encounter that acknowledges the divinity in the other person, right? You can have a, a hookup that is an I-thou hookup, and you're like, "Yeah, look, we're both creations of God, and I'll never talk to you again." Or you can have an

Alissa Wise 17:10

Right.

Ariana 17:10

and objectify the person, and they feel it.

Alissa Wise 17:12

Yeah

Ariana 17:13

and so I think it could be a kiss of greatness, maybe

Alissa Wise 17:21

But he, but right, it's like then we have to make meaning of what was happening with his tears. Like, why did he break into... just to say the context, which you didn't say before, is like he had just, he- Rachel strolls up to the well with her flock and her father. And, and he rolls... Well, this is another thing that I felt like they missed an opportunity to make some kind of sexual reference, because in the verse before, it says that he rolled the stone off the mouth of the well and watered the flock of his uncle Laban. So right, like, you could, like, picture him, like, like, rolling the stone off the well. You know, just like a little, like, that was a little, like-

Ariana 18:05

that he's like, "Ah," and just does a feat of strength. He's just so enamored. I mean, She is his extended relative, so maybe it's in that category

Alissa Wise 18:15

Oh, there you go, Rabbi, Rabbi Katz wins the prize. So then in, in the, in the Bereishit Rabba, Rabbi Tanchum pops in and says, "You're missing one category, the kiss of kinship." Jacob, Rachel was his relative. This was a kiss of kinship. It wasn't slutty. So that's how it gets resolved, but very good.

Ariana 18:43

What

Alissa Wise 18:43

What do you feel? You look, you seem disappointed

Ariana 18:46

No, I'm having emotions. They look similar. The, because we pull from the m- piece of the story where he has to, he marries Leah 'cause he didn't notice who he was marrying. And because of that moment, there is just so much around him beholding these women and the experience of it. And I think I'm just, I'm wanting that moment of seeing Rachel and just bursting into tears as the same sort of experience you would have of being in

Alissa Wise 19:19

Hmm. Hmm

Ariana 19:21

so I, I'm wanting it to be like the anointing of the king or,

Alissa Wise 19:26

you don't want it to be, like, just lust

Ariana 19:30

I don't, I think that's great, and I think just a horny Jacob, like, pushing a big rock 'cause he doesn't know what to do is awesome. But I... There is also just a like, "Oh my God, it's you," and that isn't just romance. That is also something involving seeing God

Alissa Wise 19:49

Right. Yeah. Okay, well let's keep go- L-

Ariana 19:52

the record show they're cousins

Alissa Wise 19:54

Yes, right, exactly. Okay, let's go on. The, I have two more examples from this parsha of romance and sexuality. Shall we continue forward?

Ariana 20:05

you for this gift you have brought me and everyone

Alissa Wise 20:07

Okay. I know, it's very fun. Okay. Now, we're gonna go to 28:21. So we're not go- as I said before, we're not going order of the parsha.

Ariana 20:15

This is the ASMR of pages turning in the Torah for our listeners

Alissa Wise 20:19

Oh, yeah. I, I like to have an actual book. I know it's on the internet, but I went to rabbinical school before Sefaria, so I'm like an old school Torah learner.

Ariana 20:31

She knows how to use a concordance

Alissa Wise 20:33

I know, exactly. Okay. So We're now gonna move on to a different word that the rabbis, This is another thing the rabbis love to do, is, like, take a word and just, like, rock with it, right? Like, what are all the different ways, right? That, So this, this next word is derech. What... Do you have any connotation of derech as

Ariana 21:06

way or path

Alissa Wise 21:08

Yeah, like have, have you ever heard of it as like a sexual, having a sexual te- reli- tender?

Ariana 21:17

I

Alissa Wise 21:17

is-

Ariana 21:18

danger of going off the derech, going off the path is how frum folks will refer to someone who leaves that particular orientation towards Judaism.

Alissa Wise 21:27

Yeah

Ariana 21:28

there's sex off the derech, but no, otherwise, no

Alissa Wise 21:31

Yeah. Okay, so all right. So in the Parsha, the, the way the word derech comes is in 28:20 "Jacob then made a vow saying, 'If God remains with me, if God protects me on this journey that I am making and gives me bread to eat and clothing to wear, and if I return safe to my father's house, the Lord shall be my God.'" Okay, so Jacob's kind of s- making a vow. Just to put an asterisk here, the rabbis are very upset about the vow. As some may remember from such highlights of the Jewish year as Kol Nidre, there's a very ambivalent relationship with vow-making in Jewish tradition. So Jacob makes a vow here. If this, if we weren't gonna be talking about sex today, we would be talking about vow-making. Okay, so in that, there, the word derech comes up. The English was, "He protects me on this journey," «ushmarani ba-derech,» right? So the rabbis are kind of pick up on derech, so they're like, "When else have we heard about derech?" And so the first thing that they come, they draw upon is a verse from Jeremiah where they drew their their tongues, their bows of falsehood. So they're kind of saying, "He will keep me..." They're kind of saying the thing that they're gonna be, he's gonna be kept from is evil speech, right? So they're making a little pun even though the, the word in Jeremiah is a little bit different than just derech, but they're having fun with the language. And so then they go on, "And give me bread to eat." And then the Bereishit Rabba, well, and give me bread to eat seems like a reasonable thing. Like, Jacob is saying, "If God will help me survive," right? Like, and give... Like, have there be food on... Like, it's like this is not a place where I would be like, "Oh, I bet this is a sexual innuendo." But the rabbis say this is a sexual innuendo, That the phrase, "And will give me bread to eat" means keep me from illicit sexual relationships.

Ariana 23:39

What?

Alissa Wise 23:40

I was like, out, like, out of nowhere. Like, why? Why is, why would give me bread to eat be, And Rashi comes in and says the bread means his, like, sexual relationships with his wife, and the scripture is using a euphemism

Ariana 24:02

It sounds like they were just looking for an opportunity to talk about that

Alissa Wise 24:05

I, that's what I feel. That is what I feel. Like, why, why was that a thing?

Ariana 24:11

Listen, you and I are no better than our great teachers who will find a tiny hook and run with it. Like sometimes you gotta do that

Alissa Wise 24:18

Yes. I mean, yeah.

Ariana 24:21

Huh.

Alissa Wise 24:22

okay. So, so then, so then Ibn Ezra comes in and says this, people have been saying, but it's kind of funny 'cause when he says that, he means, like, over hundreds of years in this, in this text that it's a euphemism for having sex, right? But Ibn Ezra's like, "This is far-fetched," right? And we're like, "Oh, okay." And the reason it's far-fetched is 'cause one of the proof texts they use to justify that it's sexual relations is about Potiphar, right, from the Egyptian,

Ariana 25:02

Oh

Alissa Wise 25:03

What, what's the word? Magistracy. And the reason it's far-fetched is 'cause Potiphar was a eunuch. So you can't use a proof text

Ariana 25:12

mi- but that's a midrash.

Alissa Wise 25:14

Yes. Right, so if,

Ariana 25:15

another midrash. None of this is in the

Alissa Wise 25:17

yes.

Ariana 25:17

Yes.

Alissa Wise 25:19

Yeah, so what do you know about Midrash? Yeah.

Ariana 25:22

So Ibn Ezra is saying, Rashi, this doesn't hold any water because bread can't be sex 'cause the verse that you're using bread to be sex from is from a verse of someone who can't have sex

Alissa Wise 25:39

Right. Exactly. So he's like s- yeah

Ariana 25:44

I don't even understand the first hook though,

Alissa Wise 25:46

What's the first

Ariana 25:47

sex. Like, how did we even get from derech to

Alissa Wise 25:52

Oh, sorry. Yes. That is the proof text is Genesis 39. Here, I'm gonna flip my page here. I hope everybody enjoys the page flipping sound. Is it? Oh, that's nice. Okay. Let's see. 39:6. Okay. "He left all that he had in Joseph's hands, and with him there he paid attention to nothing save the food that he ate. Now Joseph was well-built and handsome." Do you re- like there's this... Right? And then that's when his master's wife casts her eyes at Joseph, right? That's when Potiphar's like, "He's hot," right? Like, and so

Ariana 26:34

is in that verse?

Alissa Wise 26:35

yes

Ariana 26:36

Okay. But so is bread and so is lust.

Alissa Wise 26:40

Yes. Yes, exactly

Ariana 26:42

Ibn Ezra's not buying this. He's saying that's

Alissa Wise 26:44

saying... Yeah. Okay. But now, right. Okay, so now back to Breishit Rabah. They are part of this kind of chain of, like, does the bread and the derech mean sex, right? And so they go back, like, they have, in the Breishit Rabah they say, "No, it means idol worship. No, it means lashon hara," like evil speech. And then comes, like, then the, like, final thing is, "Derech is nothing other than illicit sexual relations." And the proof text for that is from Proverbs, where it says, "So is the derech, the way, of an adulterous woman." So there's this idea that this, in going, reading back to the verse, that the verse that we're in, in our, in our parsha, right, is that he's, because there's this, like, sexual, like, this relationship with Rachel that's going on where he wants Rachel, but Leah, that he's kind of, the vow he's making is trying to get God to protect him from his own illicit sexual desires

Ariana 28:04

Ah, so because this happens before he meets Rachel and Leah, it's creating... to be able to time travel and ping around in the timeline so much when you study Torah, and especially

Alissa Wise 28:15

Yes, exactly

Ariana 28:17

the vow that Yaakov is making to God is, "Save me from making mistakes around sex and intimacy," and then

Alissa Wise 28:25

Yeah

Ariana 28:26

of him not getting to marry Rachel first is that vow coming into

Alissa Wise 28:32

Right

Ariana 28:32

it's proving God's protection and power.

Alissa Wise 28:35

Yes.

Ariana 28:36

All

Alissa Wise 28:37

Exactly. Okay

Ariana 28:39

make sense of why we have this myth of trickery that he has to deal with

Alissa Wise 28:43

Right. Exactly. It's almost as if his vowing, his wishing that God will protect him from these things, whether it be idol worship, evil speech, or, you know, sluttery, is that is Yaakov's redemption in the eyes of the rabbis, right? Even that he's,

Ariana 29:07

Nice

Alissa Wise 29:08

asking for that kind of protection means that's... So then if you read it and he kisses R- Rachel out of wedlock or, like, is, like, things that you might think, this is actually proof that he's actually asking for protection of that and that redeems him.

Ariana 29:25

It's a challenge for him.

Alissa Wise 29:27

Yeah. All right. Last but not least, the mandrake. What is your relation- what do you know about a mandrake?

Ariana 29:37

it from Torah, from this

Alissa Wise 29:39

Yeah.

Ariana 29:40

seen one in real life

Alissa Wise 29:42

okay, so a mandrake has a long history. It actually appears in, like, engraved in Egyptian tombs and was, like, really a part of Egyptian culture. It is a root and it's kind of famous for that it can look like a human, the root itself. Like, the way that it grows can kind of grow, like, legs and arms off the root. You could, like, Google a mandrake and get the visual if you need. So what's interesting about a mandrake is that... And so part of its, the reason it's been kind of an ancient You know, an ancient herb that has kind of emerged in different cultures throughout time, right? There's, like, the Egyptian tombs, but also there was, like, a papyrus that was found in, like, 1500 of before the Common Era, right? Like, a long time that people have been playing with this mandrake. And so it has had different valences. One of the things that is powerful about it is that it is deadly. If you eat too much of it ingest too much of it, you will die. But if you ingest a microdose of it, you will have hallucinations, and you will... It's like a Psychedelic? And it is an aphrodisiac, for our purposes. It is known to be that. So so later, like, people started using it, like, er- in the early part of the Common Era, people used it as, like, a sedative and an anesthetic for surgical procedures, right? So it has a lot of different uses, the mandrake. So, you know, on some level it's a, it's just, like, a root and, and a plant medicine. You know, over time people would talk about it as a, like, what you should use to make, like, a love potion. If you look it up in our, our Jewish learning dictionaries, they define it as a love apple. L-

Ariana 31:55

Oh

Alissa Wise 31:56

a love hyphen apple, which I enjoyed, and, like, the subdefinition is as exciting sexual desire. So, but part of that is that then it starts get using- get to get used as a medicine for, like, infertility. So it's not clear if anybody, if, what it has to do with actual helping people get pregnant because it's like if it's just, it's...

Ariana 32:24

sex, right

Alissa Wise 32:25

Right. Exactly. Like, which one, right? Okay. So in our parsha, we, the mandrakes are kind of in this vein of, like, being used to help Rachel have babies, right? So Leah and Rach- Leah is the first wife who Jacob wasn't in love with. She does have babies. And Rachel i- has a hard time becoming pregnant. She uses her maidservant to be a surrogate. There's all kinds of fertility stuff that goes on. So now mandrakes appear in, throughout the Torah in, in all different kinds of places. There's, One of the other things that it's known for that I should say is, like, their fragrance. They're, like, apparently very fragrant. And perhaps that's part of the aphrodisiac effect, right? So different commentators over the centuries have kind of like offered more, some insight on the mandrake, right? So there is a little bit of a... The Ramban, who's in the 13th century says they resemble the human form, right, as they have the shape of human heads and hands, right? And so there is a little bit like, I don't know if I'm just reading my modern sensibility onto it, but there is a little bit of a like, was this an ancient sex toy element of, of things, right? Like, as they're talking about it having this like human form, it's, has this aphrodisiac power. I don't know. It's, and especially the shape of it if you look it up, right? So then Sforno is a 16th century commentator. And he talks about how it's primarily an aphrodisiac and stimulates human organs to, around conceiving and giving birth, right? And talks about it's one of the things that you might wanna give, just like garlic has this reputation, on Friday nights, you give your, the husband a little mandrake so that he wants to have sex with his wife on a Friday night.

Ariana 34:47

when I read it always seemed like this was Rachel begging Reuven Reuven's the one who

Alissa Wise 34:57

Yeah. Yeah. the Sun. Yeah.

Ariana 35:00

son for this mandrake because read it as it was a treatment for her inability to have children. And it's really important here that the might be conflating desire for sex with ability to conceive. But I always read it as a medicinal treatment for her, but now it sounds like maybe there is a,

Alissa Wise 35:22

Right. So the issue is the rabbis don't want it to be a medicinal treatment for her because she gets pregnant thanks to God's will. So it was a blessing from God, so it can't be that the mandrake was medicinal because that undermines God's power. Like,

Ariana 35:43

women using plant medicine to conceive, that is not in favor of the rabbi's agenda. We have to

Alissa Wise 35:50

Well, in this story, I- it's like, it's like, yes, like this is, this is like, it ha- you have to maintain that Rachel got pregnant because God willed it, and it was God's power that got her pregnant. It couldn't have been the mandrake. Even though maybe it was, you know? So then we get the mandrake in the horniest of the books of the Tanakh, Shir HaShirim, Song of Songs. Yeah. So the mandrake, you know, there's a verse in Shir HaShirim 7:13, the love between the beloved and his bride is pictured at its apex, where the beloved describes his love as utterly beautiful and graceful, and she responds by noting that all of nature is ripe for the consummation of their love and that she only waits for him. And it uses, part of the thing with, to mention here, and this is the rabbis, another way that the rabbis love to do meaning-making is, like, by puns, right? So we haven't talked about the Hebrew. So there, the He- the word mandrake is dodi'im, which

Ariana 36:58

Oh

Alissa Wise 36:58

dodi is beloved, right? And so it does have an aleph in there. It's dalet, vav, dalet, aleph, yud, right? But you could see how the rabbis could have fun of, like, putting a mandrake in for beloved, right? So there's this other exploration of the mandrake around them giving forth their fragrance, right? So I think that there's some anxiety about this aphrodisiac being widely available, 'cause, like, what if it's making everybody They have a thing where the mandrakes actually, the mandrakes actually only give off their scent and the aphrodisiac effect to their owners. Like, if you

Ariana 37:45

What?

Alissa Wise 37:46

So it's like you couldn't just, like, get a mandrake out of the ground. If you were, like, on a hike and you found a mandrake, you would you... It wouldn't have the same effect as if, like, it was your own mandrake from the own fie- your own field that you

Ariana 38:06

this is in the Midrash?

Alissa Wise 38:08

Yeah. So, There's, you know, they talk about, you know, there's a lot of like, there's like a final verse in Shir HaShirim where, not a final, but the final verse that I selected from Shir HaShirim, which I feel like kind of like brings it all together, which is "The mandrakes yield their fragrance. At our doors are all choice fruits. But freshly picked and long stored have I kept my beloved for you." So in here, this is this idea that the mandrake is a like symbol of the, of their sexual desire, right? And so and this image of like the doors will open, I think we can imagine what that opening door would actually be. Eyebrow, eyebrow.

Ariana 39:00

Yes, it is medium, so thank you for

Alissa Wise 39:03

yes.

Ariana 39:04

the eyebrows.

Alissa Wise 39:04

we had to narr- narrate the eyebrows, right? And but this idea that, so both freshly picked and long stored have I kept my beloved for you. So here the phrase my beloved, as we were just talking about, like dodi and

Ariana 39:17

Right

Alissa Wise 39:19

like I have kept my mandrakes for you, right? So it's like kind of like a metaphor of like I'm storing up my aphrodisiac herbs just for you. Like, I'm not going around... Right. And so In summary, we have here in this parsha kind of like all these different kind of references to, sexual desire, right? And I think part of what is interesting about this thing of, like, it's kind of framed that Rachel uses the mandrake to get pregnant, right? But it's almost as if it's, like, underscoring that the relationship with Leah was one that was forced upon him and was successful in sons, right? They don't... I don't think they mention any daughters that she had, but sons. And that the relationship with Rachel is actually the horny one, right? It's like they actually, right from the beginning, like, he kissed her and he sobbed, right? And he- they use the man- the mandrakes are kind of a symbol of their lust for one another. But I do find it a very curious thing, which I feel like the rabbis could have done more with, but here we are two rabbis, so we can do more with, of like wh- what... If it's not Reuven helping his aunt get pregnant with his father's, with his mother, and it is, like, him giving her a, like, sex toy of sorts, or a sexual arousal tool, like, what do we do with that?

Ariana 41:04

Well, there's some, There's some real inappropriate sexual relationships between Reuven and his stepmothers throughout. later he will try to, or sleep with Bilhah, the enslaved woman for his mother, right? And that's why he's written out of the long-term inheritance. So Reuven is already in this very weird situation in these family relationships. think I'm much more comforted by a reading that he was getting his mother, his stepmom some infertility treatment. I really don't like that reading that you're bringing. It really freaks me out. But also there

Alissa Wise 41:46

Bringing it because they're saying, the rabbis are saying the mandrakes weren't the reason she got pregnant

Ariana 41:51

Okay, I won't blame you for it. I'll blame,

Alissa Wise 41:53

Yeah. Yeah

Ariana 41:55

there is if, this is the explicit episode so far, if we're talking about how sexual desire is a good thing when put in the right direction, right? Like, Desire for your spouse that you're already married to is good and important,

Alissa Wise 42:13

Yeah

Ariana 42:13

it asks us to imagine a world in which there isn't shame around sex and desire and having children. And so asking, being able to say, you know, "Nephew, you know, we're trying to get pregnant. This would help us. Can I please... would you help me get this?" Whatever it is, requires us to imagine a world before sex stigma, which I don't think is possible because we get that stigma in the garden. but if we're going with the rabbi's read that says that it's an aphrodisiac, it's a sex toy, it's not it's not infertility drugs it is appropriate because there is not a... not an inappropriate sexual overture, God forbid, to a, a child in the family, God forbid. It's a, "This is just a normal part of life. It's on the grocery list. Can

Alissa Wise 43:10

Yeah.

Ariana 43:10

it up for me?"

Alissa Wise 43:12

Right

Ariana 43:12

drama. There is... It is a moment of conflict because she's asking her competition's child to do it.

Alissa Wise 43:19

Yeah

Ariana 43:20

goes

Alissa Wise 43:22

Well, I feel like we should take from this parsha that the complicated ways in which even in this moment, in this, in our time of the interrelationships between fertility, infertility, sex, you know, there's lots of ways that those things are very separate in our lives, and for some of us they're very together, and this is an ancient dynamic and an ancient problem. And may all those who want to have babies have them in whatever ways are possible, and may all those who want to have vibrant sexual lives figure out how to have those, too

Ariana 44:08

Mm-hmm. Amen Are invited by our teacher, Judith Plaskow, to build a Haftarah outside of conquest, and

Alissa Wise 44:19

yeah

Ariana 44:20

what text you would bring from our contemporary world or our tradition that would be the companion to the themes

Alissa Wise 44:28

To this...

Ariana 44:30

Yeah

Alissa Wise 44:30

Oh, that's fun. I wasn't prepa- I think maybe you did tell me you were gonna ask me that, but did I think about it ahead of time? No, I didn't. I think

Ariana 44:40

t- up to your tits in Midrash

Alissa Wise 44:42

Yeah, exactly. I don't, I feel like it would have to be some k- I don't know that I know the exact text, but it would have to be some kind of text about, like, ethical non-monogamy. Do you know? Like, I feel like those are kind of, like, around these... I know that there was one m- many years ago called, like, The Ethical Slut, but I don't know if that's still in vogue. I wouldn't wanna say anything that now is out of date. But, you know, I feel like, you know, non-monogamy is, is in vogue right now in our cultural milieu, and I think there's... This is also a story of non-monogamy, right? And and it really, I don't think, is up to snuff ethically. And actually, that was, like, the runner-up topic I wanted to talk to you about, about, like, how do we read ethics. I had a teacher who taught me Masorti Jewish ethics, who always taught me, like, it's actually your job to read the text ethically. Like, until you have to read it and read it and read it until it's ethical. So next time, let's try to do that

Ariana 45:49

Okay, great. Next year. yeah, I mean, Jacob is a terrible hinge. He's a terrible hinge between his many partners.

Alissa Wise 45:56

Yeah, yeah.

Ariana 45:57

I love that. Thank you. Amazing. Rabbi Elissa Wise, thank you so much for teaching us Torah. I said it at the top, and I mean it at the bottom. And to everyone who's listening, Shabbat Shalom

Alissa Wise 46:07

Shabbat Shalom

46:12

Thank you for listening to this week's episode of Left at Sinai, Parshat Vayetze with Rabbi Alyssa Wise. Your support for Left at Sinai allows us to put out episodes weekly for the coming year. Head to our GoFundMe, link in the show notes, to contribute to the show. You can sponsor an episode of learning in honor or in memory of someone, and give at any level. Transcripts, source sheets, and show notes can be found at arianakatz.com/leftatsinai

Next
Next

Parshat Chayyei Sarah with Rabbi Brant Rosen